Breathing retraining: A rational placebo?

https://doi.org/10.1016/0272-7358(92)90111-KGet rights and content

Abstract

Breathing retraining of patients with Hyperventilation Syndrome (HVS) and/or panic disorder is discussed to evaluate its clinical effectiveness and to examine the mechanism that mediates its effect. In relation to this theoretical question, the validity of HVS as a scientific model is discussed and is deemed insufficient. It is concluded that breathing retraining and related procedures are therapeutically effective, but probably due to principles other than originally proposed, namely decreasing the tendency to hyperventilate. An alternative principle is the induction of a relaxation response, presenting a credible explanation for the threatening symptoms, giving a distracting task to practice when panic may occur, and promoting a feeling of control.

References (54)

  • H. Hornsveld et al.

    Symptom reporting during voluntary hyperventilation and mental load: Implications for diagnosing Hyperventilation Syndrome

    Journal of Psychosomatic Research

    (1990)
  • R. Ley

    Blood, breath, and fears: A hyperventilation theory of panic attacks and agoraphobia

    Clinical Psychology Review

    (1985)
  • R.M. Rapee

    A case of panic disorder treated with breathing retraining

    Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry

    (1985)
  • R.M. Rapee

    The psychological treatment of panic attacks: Theoretical conceptualization and review of evidence

    Clinical Psychology Review

    (1987)
  • R.L. Rice

    Symptom patterns of the Hyperventilation Syndrome

    The American Journal of Medicine

    (1950)
  • P.M. Salkovskis et al.

    A demonstration of acute hyperventilation during naturally occurring panic attacks

    Behaviour Research and Therapy

    (1986)
  • A. Bandura

    Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change

    Psychological Review

    (1977)
  • C. Bass et al.

    Fear talk versus voluntary hyperventilation in agoraphobics and normals: A controlled study

    Psychological Medicine

    (1989)
  • E.B. Brown

    Physiological effects of hyperventilation

    Physiological Reviews

    (1953)
  • J.M. Da Costa

    On irritable heart; A clinical study of a form of functional cardiac disorder and its consequences

    American Journal of the Medical Sciences

    (1871)
  • P.van Doorn et al.

    Control of the end-tidal PCO2 in the Hyperventilation Syndrome: Effects of biofeedback and breathing instructions compared

    Bulletin Européen de Physiopathologie Respiratoire

    (1982)
  • R.van Dyck

    Psychotherapie, placebo en suggestie

    (1986)
  • P.M.G. Emmelkamp

    Phobic and obsession-compulsive disorders

    (1982)
  • H. Folgering

    Diagnostiek van het Hyperventilatie Syndroom

    Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Geneeskunde

    (1986)
  • J.D. Frank

    Persuasion and healing. A comparative study of psychotherapy

    (1973)
  • B. Garssen

    Role of stress in the development of the Hyperventilation Syndrome

    Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics

    (1980)
  • B. Garssen et al.

    Clinical aspects and treatment of the Hyperventilation Syndrome

    Behavioural Psychotherapy

    (1986)
  • Cited by (63)

    • Sigh rate during emotional transitions: More evidence for a sigh of relief

      2017, Biological Psychology
      Citation Excerpt :

      Because of these close interactions and the fact that breathing is under voluntary control, respiration is a popular target for treatments aiming to reduce negative emotional states, and breathing-focused therapies have been applied to various physiological and psychological disorders. Since interventions for anxiety and anxiety disorders often include breathing training (e.g. Garssen, de Ruiter, & van Dyck, 1992; Meuret, Wilhelm, Ritz, & Roth, 2003) and respiratory phenomena have been thought to be central to some anxiety disorders (Klein, 1993; Ley, 1985), research on anxiety and breathing is particularly interesting and important. Multiple reviews report a rather consistent pattern of breathing changes when anxiety or fear are induced (Boiten, Frijda, & Wientjes, 1994; Homma and Masaoka, 2008; Kreibig, 2010).

    • Feedback of end-tidal pCO<inf>2</inf> as a therapeutic approach for panic disorder

      2008, Journal of Psychiatric Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      Finally, what was taught in the exercises may have served as an anxiety-reducing distraction. Indeed, it has been argued that breathing training may distract from experiencing anxiety in exposure therapy and thereby reduce its efficacy (Craske et al., 1997; Schmidt et al., 2000; Garssen et al., 1992). However, even if distraction had been part of the mechanism of action in our training, its effects do not seem to have interfered substantially with the overall beneficial outcome of the training, which was comparable to that of standard CBT protocols.

    • Hyperventilation

      2007, Encyclopedia of Stress
    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text