Table 3

Results for end of TB therapy assessment compared with baseline for all those assessed at both time points, using the CPA categorisation at the second time point

SymptomsEarly TB therapy (n=128)End of therapy (n=128)P valueCPA* (n=10)non-CPA (n=118)P value
Gender
 Male52 (41%)52 (41%)5 (50%)47 (40%)
 Female76 (59%)76 (59%)5 (50%)71 (60%)0.526
Age (mean; range)38.3 (17–77)38.3 (17–77)52 (22–77)37.1 (17–72) 0.004
Symptoms
(>3 months)
 Cough22 (17%)18 (14%)0.5565 (50%)13 (11%) 0.005
 Fatigue9 (7%)21 (17%) 0.031 6 (60%)15 (13%) 0.001
 Dyspnoea7 (6%)16 (13%)0.0643 (30%)13 (11%)0.111
 Chest pain6 (5%)7 (6%)12 (20%)5 (4%)0.094
 Weight loss5 (4%)3 (2%)0.72703 (3%)1.000
 Haemoptysis3 (2%)3 (2%)0.7271 (10%)2 (2%)0.218
Intermittent haemoptysis
(<3 months)
24 (19%)3 (2%) <0.001 1 (14%)2 (3%)0.286
Radiology
 Infiltrates123 (96%)102 (80%) <0.001 8 (80%)94 (80%)1.000
 Cavitation67 (52%)45 (35%) <0.001 7 (70%)38 (32%) 0.033
 Paracavitary
 fibrosis
43 (34%)28 (22%) 0.001 4 (40%)24 (20%)0.224
 Pleural thickening32 (25%)31 (24%)15 (50%)26 (22%)0.061
 Nodules23 (18%)15 (12%) 0.039 015 (13%)0.605
 Air fluid level in cavities21 (16%)4 (3%) <0.001 1 (10%)3 (3%)0.281
 Aspergilloma†3 (2%)4 (3%)11 (10%)3 (3%)0.281
 Bronchiectasis8 (6%)13 (10%)0.1251 (10%)12 (10%)1.000
  • Bold values indicate statistical significance.

  • *Proven CPA.

  • †One aspergilloma at baseline (non-CPA) was confirmed on CT scan, the rest were unconfirmed aspergilloma diagnosed on chest X-ray.

  • CPA, chronic pulmonary aspergillosis.