Table 1

Participant characteristics, stratified by HIV status*

CharacteristicTotalHIV-negativeHIV-positiveP value
(n=405)(n=159)(n=244)
Age (years) (median, IQR)35 (28–41)30 (24–37)37 (32–42)<0.001
Male sex275 (67.9%)115 (72.3%)158 (64.8%)0.112
Urban socioeconomic quintile (n=372)*
 Poorest22 (5.9%)10 (7.1%)12 (5.2%)0.638
 Second poorest85 (22.8%)28 (19.9%)57 (24.9%)
 Middle95 (25.5%)36 (25.5%)58 (25.3%)
 Second most wealthy114 (30.7%)48 (34.0%)66 (28.8%)
 Most wealthy56 (15.1%)19 (13.5%)36 (15.7%)
Maximum education level ≤primary school154 (38.0%)49 (30.8%)104 (42.6%)0.017
Intermittent difficulty procuring food for household128 (31.6%)47 (29.6%)81 (33.2%)0.443
Household dissaving incurred in past 1 year to cover illness costs†298 (73.6%)109 (68.6%)189 (77.5%)0.047
Monthly individual income ($US)‡41.32 (11.02–96.42)37.47 (5.51–82.64)46.83 (16.53–99.17)0.206
Baseline TB microbiology
 Smear positive213 (52.6%)118 (74.2%)95 (38.9%)<0.001
 Xpert positive, rifampicin sensitive100 (24.7%)21 (13.2%)78 (32.0%)
 Radiological diagnosis54 (13.3%)10 (6.3%)43 (17.6%)
 Clinical diagnosis38 (9.4%)10 (6.3%)28 (11.5%)
Self-reported illness duration prior to TB treatment (weeks)8.7 (4.3–13.0)8.7 (4.3–13.0)8.7 (4.3–17.4)0.759
ART use, if HIV-positive (n=244)§224 (91.8%)
Duration on ART, if HIV-positive (months) (n=222)6.6 (5.5–25.6)
Prophylactic cotrimoxazole use, if HIV-positive (n=234)211 (90.2%)
CD4, if HIV-positive (cells/µL) (n=242)229 (127–397)
Ever smoker, cigarettes120 (29.6%)56 (35.2%)62 (25.4%)0.034
Pack years, among smokers (n=120)2.7 (0.7–6.0)2.1 (0.7–5.6)2.9 (0.7–7.0)0.465
Ever smoker, cannabis (n=362)*54 (14.9%)35 (25.4%)19 (8.6%)<0.001
Charcoal/wood as main fuel384 (94.8%)153 (96.2%)229 (93.9%)0.295
  • *Missing data: HIV status for n=2 (declined to test, included in ‘total’ column only), socioeconomic status (SES) for n=33 (unable to visit household to determine building materials), Cannabis use for n=43 (unbiased data collection error).

  • †Borrowing money, using savings, selling assets to cover costs due to illness, in past 1 year (during TB illness and treatment).

  • ‡Income data collected in Malawi Kwacha, but standardised using exchange rate at study midpoint (1 US$: 726 MK, March 2017).

  • §97% (218/224) receiving Regimen 5a (tenofovir, lamivudine, efavirenz) at TB treatment completion.

  • ART, antiretroviral therapy.