Table 3

Summary of rates of conversions and reversions in serial testing studies (N=8)

StudyDuration between testingTST converters, n/N (%)IGRA converters, n/N (%)IGRA reverters, n/N (%)
High TB incidence countries
Pai, 20061518 months6/147 (4.1%)17/147 (11.6%)7/38 (18.4%)
Joshi, 2009586 months11/57 (19%)6/22 (27%)
6 months (6–12 months)11/52* (21%)11/27 (40%)
Moderate and low TB incidence countries
Pollock, 2009641–7 months2/43 (4.6%)
Zwerling, 2009591 year0/57 (0%)4/56 (7.14%)4/5 (80%)
Yoshiyama, 2009602 and 4 years5/277 (1.8%)13/32 (41%)
Chee, 2009611 year0/189/182 (4.9%)
Lee, 2009621 year16/75 (21.3%)21/146 (14.4%)
Belknap, 2010636 months4/1202 (0.3%)TSPOT 44/1117 (3.9%)
QFT-GIT 44/1169 (3.8%)
TSPOT 36/68 (52.9%)
QFT-GIT 20/50 (40%)
Costa, 2010201–2.5 years98/199 (49.2%)51/462 (11%)46/208 (22.1%)
Ringshausen, 20102118 weeks(baseline only)3/162 (1.9%)6/18 (33.3%)
  • All conversions/reversions using simple negative/positive definition.

  • * Denominator includes only participants negative at 6 months.

  • Denominator includes only participants positive at 6 months.

  • Denominator includes only baseline concordant negatives.

  • IGRA, interferon-gamma release assay; PPD, purified protein derivative; TB, tuberculosis; TST, tuberculin skin test.