Table 2 Effect of placebo (PL) and ipratropium bromide (IB) on pulmonary function tests in patients with GOLD stage I COPD
Post-PLPost-IB
FEV1 (l)2.30 (0.60), (83%)2.46 (0.59), (88%)*
ΔFEV1 (l)0.07 (0.09), (3%)†0.26 (0.19), (9%)†‡
FVC (l)4.07 (1.13), (103%)4.20 (1.17), (106%)*
ΔFVC (l)0.02 (0.18), (1%)0.23 (0.21), (6%)†‡
FEV1/FVC (%)57 (7), (81%)59 (7), (83%)
ΔFEV1/FVC (%)1.3 (2.0), (2%)†2.9 (3.2), (4%)†
Tlco (ml/min/mm Hg)21.0 (6.2), (94%)20.2 (6.5), (90%)
ΔTlco (ml/min/mm Hg)−0.1 (1.4), (−1%)−1.1 (2.3), (−5%)
MIP (cm H2O)96 (20), (120%)98 (21), (121%)
ΔMIP (cm H2O)−1 (11), (−2%)1.6 (7.7), (1%)
MEP (cm H2O)148 (54), (82%)148 (48), (83%)
ΔMEP (cm H2O)1 (12), (1%)−6 (13), (−10%)
TLC (l)7.16 (1.49), (114%)7.04 (1.42), (112%)
ΔTLC (l)−0.03 (0.26), (−1%)−0.15 (0.20), (−3%)†
RV (l)2.73 (0.34), (125%)2.49 (0.47), (113%)*
ΔRV (l)−0.14 (0.19), (−6%)†−0.38 (0.22), (−19%)†‡
FRC (l)4.05 (0.71), (121%)3.90 (0.82), (115%)*
ΔFRC (l)−0.07 (0.17), (−2%)−0.27 (0.29), (−9%)†‡
IC (l)3.10 (1.01), (106%)3.15 (0.86), (109%)
ΔIC (l)0.04 (0.19), (1%)0.12 (0.32), (4%)
sRaw (cm H2O.s)12.7 (4.3), (301%)9.3 (4.6), (220%)*
ΔsRaw (cm H2O.s)−0.6 (1.7), (−15%)−4.7 (3.5), (−111%)†‡
  • Values are mean (SD), (% predicted normal values).

  • *p<0.05, post-IB vs post-PL.

  • †p<0.05 post-dose vs pre-dose within treatment.

  • ‡p<0.05 IB vs PL post-dose minus pre-dose differences.

  • Δ, post-dose minus pre-dose difference; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1 s; FVC, forced vital capacity; IC, inspiratory capacity; MIP, maximal inspiratory pressure; MEP, maximal expiratory pressure; PEF, peak expiratory flow; RV, residual volume; sRaw, specific airway resistance; SVC, slow vital capacity; TLC, total lung capacity; Tlco, carbon monoxide transfer factor.