Author | N | Study type | Intervention | Duration | Outcomes | Comments | |
Sullivan74 | 2 | Case reports | CPAP | 1–3 months | ↑Pao2; ↓Paco2; ↓oedema; ↓EDS; ↑mentation | ↓Reduced SDB off therapy | |
Piper78 | 13 | Retrospective | NIV | 3 months | Improved ABGs | Long-term CPAP effective in 9/13 subjects | |
Berg37 | 20 | Retrospective | BPAP or CPAP | 2 years | 68% ↓hospitalisations following therapy | ||
Hida38 | 26 | Before/after | CPAP | 3 months | ↓EDS; improved QoL | ||
de Miguel Diez57 | 12 | Before/after | BPAP withdrawal | 3 months | No change in weight, daytime or nocturnal ABGs with treatment withdrawal; slight ↓ΔP0.1/ΔPaco2, ΔVE/ΔPaco2 | 12/22 patients managed off BPAP; 7/12 demonstrated OSA and required CPAP therapy | |
Storre80 | 10 | RCT, crossover | BPAP-S/T ±AVAPS | 6 weeks | Improved sleep quality on BPAP; improved QoL; ↓Ptcco2 during sleep on BPAP | BPAP with AVAPS more effective in ↓ CO2 but no additional effects on sleep or QoL. CPAP non-responders studied | |
Banerjee77 | 23 | Prospective | CPAP | 1 night | Improved sleep quality, ↓AHI and improved oxygenation compared with baseline | 43% of OHS patients studied continued to desaturate <90% for >20% of TST | |
Piper79 | 36 | RCT | CPAP vs BPAP | 3 months | Comparable improvements in awake CO2 and Spo2; subjective sleep quality better with BPAP; no difference in compliance | Subset of OHS patients without severe persistent REM hypoventilation on CPAP. Majority of patients managed longer term with CPAP | |
Chouri-Pontarollo50 | 15 | Before/after | BPAP | 5 nights | ↓EDS; ↓AHI; improved objective vigilance in those with low CO2 responses | Daytime ventilatory responses to CO2 associated with amount of REM hypoventilation and daytime sleepiness |
ABG, arterial blood gas; AHI, apnoea-hypopnoea index; AVAPS, average volume assured pressure support; BPAP, bilevel positive airway pressure; CPAP, continuous positive airway pressure; EDS, excessive daytime somnolence; NIV, non-invasive ventilation; OHS, obesity hypoventilation syndrome; OSA, obstructive sleep apnoea; P0.1, occlusion pressure; Paco2, Pao2, arterial carbon dioxide and oxygen tensions; QoL, quality of life; RCT, randomised controlled trial; REM, rapid eye movement; SDB, sleep-disordered breathing; Spo2, oxygen saturation; TST, total sleep time; VE, minute ventilation.