Article Text

other Versions


Mortality from infectious pneumonia in metal workers: a comparison with deaths from asthma in occupations exposed to respiratory sensitizers
  1. Keith T Palmer (ktp{at}
  1. Medical Reseach Council, United Kingdom
    1. Paul Cullinan (p.cullinan{at}
    1. National Heart and Lung Institute, United Kingdom
      1. Simon Rice (simon.rice{at}
      1. Health and Safety Laboratory, United Kingdom
        1. Terry Brown (t.p.brown{at}
        1. Cranfield University, United Kingdom
          1. David Coggon (dnc{at}
          1. Medical Reseach Council, United Kingdom


            Introduction: National analyses of mortality in England and Wales have repeatedly shown excess deaths from pneumonia in welders. During 1979-1990 the excess was attributable largely to deaths from lobar pneumonia and pneumonias other than bronchopneumonia, limited to working-aged men, and apparent in other metal fume-exposed occupations. We assessed findings for 1991-2000 and compared the mortality pattern with that from asthma in occupations exposed to known respiratory sensitizers.

            Methods: The Office of National Statistics supplied data on deaths by underlying cause among men aged 16-74 years in England and Wales during 1991-2000, including age and last held occupation. We abstracted data on pneumonia for occupations with exposure to metal fume and on asthma for occupations commonly reported to surveillance schemes as at risk of occupational asthma. We estimated expected numbers of deaths by applying age-specific proportions of deaths by cause in the population to the total deaths by age in each occupational group. Observed and expected numbers were compared for each cause of death.

            Results: Among working-aged men in metal fume-exposed occupations we found excesses of mortality from pneumococcal and lobar pneumonia (54 deaths vs. 27.3 expected) and from pneumonias other than bronchopneumonia (71 vs. 52.4), but no excess from these causes at older ages, or from bronchopneumonia at any age. The attributable mortality from metal fume (45.3 excess deaths) compared with an estimated 62.6 deaths from occupational asthma.

            Conclusion: Exposure to metal fume is a material cause of occupational mortality. The hazard deserves far more attention than it presently receives.

            Statistics from

            Review history and Supplementary material

            Request Permissions

            If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.