Background Over 50 000 patients with malignant pleural effusion (MPE) are seen annually in the UK. The majority develop recurrent symptomatic disease requiring definitive treatment. MPE is most frequently managed with talc slurry pleurodesis via intercostal chest drain. This involves a lengthy inpatient stay and has a success rate of around 70%, with no means of predicting which patients will suffer pleurodesis failure. Thoracic ultrasound (TUS) is widely used by respiratory physicians, and data from animal and human studies suggest it can identify pleural adhesions (through the absence of normal lung sliding) in a range of conditions. By extension, TUS may allow clinicians to diagnose the presence or absence of adhesions post-pleurodesis in MPE, identifying patients suitable for discharge or needing further intervention.

Method We recruited 18 adult patients with MPE undergoing drainage and talc slurry pleurodesis to a prospective single-centre cohort study. Patients underwent standardised TUS assessment pre- and post-pleurodesis, evaluating pleural sliding and adhesions at nine points (three anterior, three lateral, three posterior) across the affected hemithorax. Lung sliding was graded as per Zhu et al.,¹ creating a total pleurodesis score out of 18. Pleurodesis failure was defined as radiological and symptomatic fluid recurrence in the same hemithorax requiring further intervention at any point up to 3 months post-pleurodesis. Patients also completed a questionnaire addressing satisfaction with TUS assessment.

Results 3/18 patients (16.7%) died before 1 month follow-up. Of 15 patients seen at one month, 11 (73.3%) had successful pleurodesis and 4 (26.7%) had failed. No patient had delayed pleurodesis failure between 1 and 3 month follow-up. There was a significant difference observed in the day 1 TUS pleurodesis score between patients who went on to have successful pleurodesis and those who failed during follow-up (table 1). TUS assessment was acceptable to patients, with none considering it either time-consuming or unwilling to have it again if needed.

Conclusion Our data suggest TUS assessment 24 hours post-pleurodesis for MPE predicts success or failure of this intervention, with significant implications for clinical care. A larger randomised study is now underway to further evaluate this hypothesis.

Reference

1. Chest2005;128(2):934–9.