Objective It is unclear whether objectively measured maternal sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) leads to poor fetal outcomes. In this study, we prospectively assessed whether polysomnography-based diagnosis of SDB in the third trimester is associated with the delivery of small for gestational age (SGA) infants.
Study design Participants were recruited from a multicentre pregnancy cohort study. Eligible participants were evaluated for SDB based on symptoms (snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas assessed using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index questionnaire) and in-home complete polysomnography in the third trimester. SGA was defined as <10th centile using customised birthweight centiles adjusted for maternal parity, prepregnancy body mass index (BMI), ethnicity, gestational age and infant sex.
Results Of the 234 pregnant participants who completed a sleep study, 82% were Caucasian, with mean (SD) age of 31 (4.3) years and a prepregnancy BMI of 23 (4) kg/m2. The delivery of SGA infants occurred in 27 (12%) of the study participants. The symptoms of SDB had poor overall sensitivity and specificity for diagnosing SDB identified by polysomnography. Symptoms of SDB in the third trimester demonstrated a potential association with delivering an SGA infant, however this did not reach statistical significance (OR 2.36 (95% CI 0.85 to 6.54, p=0.10)). However, the odds of delivering an SGA infant were significantly increased with polysomnography-based diagnosis of maternal SDB (using apnoea-hypopnoea index cut-off of 10, OR 2.65 (95% CI 1.15 to 6.10, p=0.02)).
Conclusions Objectively measured SDB in the third trimester is significantly associated with the delivery of SGA infants.
- Sleep apnoea
- Clinical Epidemiology
Statistics from Altmetric.com
What is the key question?
Does maternal sleep-disordered breathing confer an increased risk of delivering babies that are small for gestational age?
What is the bottom line?
In a cohort of relatively healthy and non-obese women, we report an increased risk of delivering small for gestational age infants with maternal sleep-disordered breathing determined by polysomnography.
Why read on?
Demonstration of a link between fetal outcomes and maternal sleep-disordered breathing suggest that future clinical trials are needed to investigate whether treatment of sleep-disordered breathing in pregnancy improves the lifelong health of the newborn infant.
Infants with intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) that are born small for gestational age (SGA) are at risk for greater perinatal morbidity and mortality.1 Later in life, being born SGA may be a risk factor for developing cardiometabolic complications and neurological disabilities.2 ,3 IUGR may be caused by a variety of maternal, placental and/or fetal factors. In many cases, the exact aetiology is not identified and management is limited to close surveillance and early delivery.4 The pathophysiology of IUGR is characterised by insufficient uteroplacental blood flow due to vasoconstriction.5 ,6 Given the limited treatment options of IUGR, the identification of reversible pathogenic factors may improve fetal outcomes.
Sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) is characterised by repetitive partial or complete upper airway obstructions during sleep, resulting in sleep fragmentation and/or recurrent hypoxia-reoxygenation. Multiple downstream effects of SDB, such as haemodynamic fluctuations, increased sympathetic activity, oxidative stress, endothelial dysfunction and systemic inflammation7 ,8 have been associated with adverse cardiac and vascular sequelae in non-pregnant populations.9–,12 Animal studies have demonstrated that maternal intermittent hypoxia, a model for SDB, leads to low birth weight.13 ,14 Given the known adverse vascular consequences of untreated SDB in the general population, it is plausible that SDB during pregnancy may contribute to altered haemodynamics and diminished placental tissue perfusion, with a potential to decrease fetal growth.
A growing number of human studies indicate that symptoms of SDB increase and progress throughout pregnancy, with 14–35% of pregnant women reporting habitual snoring in the third trimester.15–17 Mechanisms of SDB are likely multifactorial and include weight gain, fluid shifts18 and rhinitis.19 ,20 A recent meta-analysis demonstrated that maternal SDB is associated with an increased risk of delivering low birthweight infants (pooled OR 1.39, 95% CI 1.14 to 1.65).21 However only two out of eight studies relied on objective, rather than subjective measures of sleep apnoea. Moreover, these two studies22 ,23 were retrospective cohort and database linkage studies. Prospective cohort studies assessing this association are therefore required. There is effective treatment for SDB (continuous positive airway pressure; CPAP), which could therefore potentially be a novel antenatal therapeutic option for preventing SGA.
The objective was to perform a prospective cohort study assessing the association between maternal SDB and infants born SGA using complete in-home (level II) polysomnography (PSG) in the third trimester. Preliminary results of this study have been previously reported in the form of abstracts.24 ,25
Participants for the SGA and maternal SDB substudy were recruited between September 2011 and March 2013 from a larger pregnancy cohort (3D Birth Cohort of the Integrated Research Network in Perinatology of Quebec and Eastern Ontario; IRNPQEO) aimed at examining determinants of various maternal and fetal outcomes. For the SGA and maternal SDB substudy, the inclusion criteria were a third trimester ultrasound that showed <75th centile predicted birth weight26 in order to minimise the number of large for gestational age babies (>90th centile birth weight) in our cohort (this criteria was applied to all participants, irrespective of SDB risk), a singleton pregnancy and no current treatment for a known sleep disorder. Study coordinators of the parent cohort approached eligible participants for participation in a research substudy on sleep in pregnancy.
In this prospective cohort study, eligible and interested participants were recruited in the third trimester and underwent a level II home sleep study soon after recruitment. The primary measure of exposure status (ie, presence or absence of SDB) was ascertained by PSG performed during the third trimester of pregnancy, since SDB is known to significantly improve after delivery.27 The study was approved at all participating institutions through the Quebec Ministry of Health Multi-Centre Research Ethics process (for which the primary reviewing site was Ste-Justine Hospital, coordinating centre for the IRNPQEO cohort study).
General cohort and outcome assessments
As part of the parent cohort study measurements, all subjects were evaluated at 10–14 weeks, 20–24 weeks and 32–35 weeks gestational age. Maternal characteristics including ethnicity, marital status, education, prepregnancy weight, smoking exposure history, and medical and obstetric history were obtained through questionnaires and chart review. A positive smoking history was defined as smoking at least an average five cigarettes/day during pregnancy. Small for gestational age was defined as a birth weight <10th centile using customised birth centile curves with a US population reference standard.28 ,29 The customised birth centiles are adjusted for infant sex, gestational age at birth and maternal constitutional factors that have been consistently found to be predictive of fetal growth28 ,29 including maternal ethnicity, parity, prepregnancy weight and height. This adjustment is made accessible through an online customised individual growth chart calculator called GROW30 (Gestational Related Optimal Weight; gestation.net) developed by Gardosi et al28 ,29 to calculate the individual customised optimal birth weight based on the aforementioned maternal and fetal characteristics, and thus allows comparison of an actual infant birth weight against its own predicted weight or optimal growth potential.
One night of in-home, complete overnight PSG (Titanium, Embla, Natus Medical, San Carlos, California, USA) was performed during the late third trimester, after the third trimester ultrasound. A sleep technologist installed the recording equipment in the participant's home on the evening of the study to verify signal quality. Scorers were blinded to the ultrasound results. Sleep-wake state, arousals and periodic limb movements were scored according to current American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) criteria.31 Respiratory events were scored using standard Chicago criteria,32 which are more sensitive than current AASM criteria.33
Sleep questionnaire data
The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI)34 was administered during the routine first and third trimester study visits. The PSQI consists of 19 self-rated questions regarding sleep quality and 5 questions that are targeted to the bed partner of the participant (if applicable). These five questions include two questions that relate to symptoms of sleep apnoea: ‘loud snoring’ and ‘long pauses between breaths while asleep’. Classification as to snoring or witnessed apnoeas was based simply on the presence or absence of these reported symptoms.
For sample size calculation, the prevalence of SDB in pregnant women is unknown. Since up to 35% of women present with symptoms of SDB in the third trimester,15 and anticipating the possibility of participation bias, we felt the rate of exposure could be similar to the rate of non-exposure depending on the threshold of the apnoea-hypopnoea index (AHI) used. Using a prevalence of SGA of 6%, among non-snorers35 we estimated that to detect an OR of ∼2.5 (based on previous symptom-based studies16 ,35) of SGA among SDB versus non-SDB with a power of 80% (β 0.2) and α 0.05, we would require a total sample size of ∼225 subjects. Means with SDs were used for descriptive statistics for continuous variables and numbers and proportions for categorical variables. Univariate logistic regression analysis was used to determine the association between SDB (using various threshold values for AHI) and other sleep parameters and delivery of an SGA infant. Logistic or linear regression modelling (depending on the outcome of interest) was used to calculate p values for trend (Cochrane–Armitage trend test36 ,37), when comparing outcome values across categories of increasing severity of AHI. An ordinal variable for AHI was created by using the median AHI of each category and the p value associated with this was used as the p value for trend. Comparisons of mean AHI, oxygen desaturation index, obstructive hypopnoea index, hypopnoea arousal index for SGA and non-SGA babies used the Student's t test. Statistical analyses were performed using JMP, V.11 (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA, 1989–2007) and R (RStudio V.0.99.441).
The participant flow diagram for recruitment and enrolment from the parent IRNPQEO cohort is shown in figure 1. Of 261 women who consented for participation in the substudy, 10% did not have a PSG for various reasons. Thus, 234 women from the parent cohort participated in the sleep substudy and completed an at-home level II PSG during the third trimester. Baseline participant characteristics are shown in table 1. Participants in the sleep substudy were predominantly non-obese (body mass index (BMI) <30 kg/m2) and Caucasian (table 1), with 6% Latin American, 3% Arabic or West Asian, 3% African American and 2% Native American. Questionnaire data revealed that a small minority smoked during pregnancy (table 1), three reported depression and none had pre-existing diabetes or hypertension. The prevalence of gestational hypertension was 3% (n=7) while gestational diabetes was reported in 7% (n=17) of pregnancies. Active asthma was reported in 9% (n=18), and only 1 participant reported active cardiovascular disease. With increasing AHI, there was a significant increase in maternal age, BMI and neck circumference (table 1).
Symptom and PSG-based evaluation of SDB
In the first trimester, 182 participants completed the PSQI and 54 (31%) reported any degree of snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas in the first trimester. This increased significantly to 87 (51%) by the third trimester (p<0.0001). There was a 35% incidence of new symptoms of SDB from the first trimester to the third trimester.
The third trimester PSG was performed at a mean of 36.6 (±1.4) weeks of gestational age. After six technical failures (3% rate), PSG data were available on 230 participants (figure 1). Since AHI cut-offs for defining SDB are not well established in pregnancy, table 1 displays demographic characteristics of the cohort as divided by severity of SDB based on various AHI categories. Using AHI cut-offs of 5 events/h, 10 events/h, 15 events/h and 30 events/h, the prevalence of SDB in this cohort was 66%, 30%, 16% and 2.6%, respectively. Table 2 demonstrates PSG sleep variables. There was a trend towards decreased PSG total sleep time and increased N1 sleep as the severity of AHI categories increased. In addition, there was significantly reduced N3 sleep but no change in rapid eye movement (REM) sleep as SDB severity increased. The mean AHI of the cohort was 9.1±8.2 events/h. As shown in table 2, SDB in the third trimester of pregnancy was predominantly characterised by obstructive hypopnoeas associated with microarousals, rather than apnoeas or events associated with oxygen desaturation.
The proportion of participants who reported snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas in the first trimester and third trimester significantly increased with severity of AHI category (figure 2). However, the sensitivity and specificity for snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas to predict maternal SDB in the third trimester, irrespective of AHI cut-off, was poor overall (table 3).
Association between symptom-based and PSG-based diagnosis of SDB and delivery of SGA infants
The total number of SGA deliveries in this cohort was 27 (12%). Gestational age and birthweight data are shown in table 4. The rate of preterm birth as defined by a gestational age at delivery of <37 weeks did not differ across AHI categories. While absolute birth weight did not differ across AHI categories (table 4), figure 3 demonstrates an increased proportion of SGA births based on customised birthweight centile born to mothers with increasing SDB severity. Furthermore, as shown in figure 4, there were significantly higher mean values for key measures of SDB severity among the mothers of infants born SGA compared with non-SGA.
In addition, almost all PSG variables, including SDB defined by various AHI thresholds (5, 10 and 15), and continuous PSG indices such as obstructive hypopnoea index, and the oxygen desaturation index (table 5), were significantly associated with an increased odds of delivering an SGA infant. While the apnoea index was not significantly associated with the delivery of an SGA baby, the mean apnoea index of the cohort was only 0.1 (table 2). The most frequent respiratory events were obstructive hypopnoeas associated with microarousals, which were significantly associated with an increased odds of delivering an SGA infant (table 5). This finding was specific for respiratory-related arousals in that there was no significant association between spontaneous microarousals and SGA.
Symptoms of snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas were not significantly associated with increased odds of delivering an SGA baby in this cohort (table 5). However, symptoms in the third trimester or new or incident symptoms (from the first to the third trimesters) suggested increased risk for delivering an SGA baby, but just failed to reach statistical significance (p=0.1 and 0.08, respectively). Neck circumference, a physical measurement that is known to be associated with SDB, was found to be associated with SGA in this cohort (OR 1.25 (95% CI 1.03 to 1.53) per 1 cm increase, p=0.026).
In a subset of our participants who had umbilical artery Doppler ultrasound in the third trimester, customised birth centiles, rather than population-based birth centiles, were significantly associated (r=−0.43; p=0.0005) with an increase in the mean resistance index, a measure which has been associated with adverse outcomes.38
In this relatively healthy and non-obese cohort, we demonstrated that a PSG-based diagnosis of SDB using various AHI thresholds in the third trimester of pregnancy was associated with a significantly increased odds of delivering an SGA baby (ORs ranging between 2.57 and 3.07; p<0.05). In addition, other PSG-based indices of SDB, including the obstructive hypopnoea index and the oxygen desaturation index, were consistently associated with an increased odds of delivering an SGA infant. Although symptoms of SDB failed to reach statistical significance for an association with the delivery of SGA babies, this may be due to limited power. The definition of SGA in our study was based on customised birth centiles (<10th centile) and was adjusted for important confounders such as maternal prepregnancy BMI, parity, ethnicity, fetal sex and gestational age at birth. These findings may have important implications for the perinatal management of maternal SDB.
We also demonstrated that in a subset of participants who completed the PSQI in the first and third trimesters (n=182), symptoms of SDB increased in parallel with AHI severity. However, symptoms of SDB were of overall poor sensitivity and specificity for predicting PSG-based diagnosis of SDB and were not predictive of delivering an SGA baby. The few previous studies examining the link between maternal SDB and the delivery of SGA babies as a primary outcome have yielded mixed results. However, the majority of studies used symptom-based assessments of SDB,15 ,16 ,35 ,39 ,40 and the timing of ascertainment of symptoms during pregnancy and exact symptom definition of SDB varied significantly. Of the two studies that used PSG-based diagnoses of SDB, one was a retrospective cohort study23 that showed no association and the other, a large database study22 demonstrated a positive association. One recent small study by Fung et al used PSG to study 51 pregnant women and identified 14 with sleep apnoea, which was associated with delivering babies with impaired fetal growth.41 These authors also used customised birthweight centiles to define SGA, but found a significant association between sleep apnoea and impaired fetal growth (defined as either a birth weight <10th centile or fall in customised centile >33% between 32 weeks and term) but not SGA defined by birth weight <10th centile alone.41 It is likely that the smaller sample size in the study by Fung et al contributed to failure to detect a significant relationship between SGA and SDB.
The use of customised birthweight centiles to define SGA, rather than population-based birth centiles, has been shown to lead to fewer misclassifications of SGA infants. Customised birthweight centiles were initially proposed by Gardosi et al28 ,29 to account for maternal characteristics that influence fetal growth, and account for maternal height, prepregnancy weight, parity, ethnicity and fetal sex. Due to the adjustments for these contributors to fetal growth, customised centiles better reflect infants who are SGA due to pathological IUGR, rather than infants who are constitutionally small but have reached their growth potential.28 ,29 Customised growth centiles have been demonstrated to be superior to conventionally used birthweight centiles that are adjusted only for infant sex and gestational age in predicting adverse maternal and fetal outcomes.42 The association between umbilical artery Doppler ultrasound and customised birth centiles that was demonstrated in a subset of our participants further suggests that SDB affects fetal growth on the basis of placental dysfunction.
In our study, most SDB in the third trimester was mild and characterised by obstructive hypopnoeas associated with microarousals, rather than by oxygen desaturations or obstructive apnoeas, as has been demonstrated previously in pregnancy.43 ,44 Thus, it is not surprising that obstructive hypopnoeas, rather than obstructive apnoeas, were associated with SGA babies since very few obstructive apnoeas were observed. Since the scoring criteria and AHI thresholds are still not well established in pregnancy, we presented our data using various AHI thresholds and PSG indices and used sensitive (Chicago) scoring criteria to avoid misclassification of SDB.
Strengths of our study included its prospective nature, and the relatively large number of participants studied late in the third trimester with complete PSG that included EEG for sleep staging, which is more accurate for AHI determination. Moreover, symptoms of SDB (snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas) were ascertained both in the first and third trimesters of pregnancy to assess the relationship with PSG measures, since this has not been well examined in the literature. We also minimised misclassification of SGA by using customised birth centiles adjusted for important maternal and fetal characteristics that can influence birth weight. We used extensive and broad definitions of SDB using various AHI cut-offs and also examined all indices of PSG-based diagnosis of SDB to ensure our associations were robust and consistent.
Our study also had important limitations. First, we only had 27 cases of SGA (12%) in our cohort, which limits statistical power and ability to control for additional potential confounding variables, such as socioeconomic status and education. On the other hand, despite the small number of cases, we were able to find statistically significant relationships across several PSG-based measurements and indices for SDB, suggesting that our findings were consistent. Another limitation is that 182 participants completed the symptom questionnaires (PSQI), and thus we were left with missing data. Despite the limited sensitivity and specificity of symptoms (table 3), we did see some potential associations of symptoms in the third trimester and new incident symptoms with delivery of SGA infants. Thus, the smaller sample size from non-response resulted in more limited power with respect to finding a significant relationship between symptoms and delivery of SGA babies. We also used different thresholds to define symptom-based SDB (ie, snoring and/or witnessed apnoeas at any frequency, symptoms >1×/week, or≥3×/week), and there was no significant change in the results. Furthermore, since we did not have a PSG during the first trimester, we could not assess whether objective first trimester PSG findings impact the risk of delivering an SGA baby. We also cannot draw conclusions on whether it is new or incident SDB during pregnancy versus pre-existing SDB that is a risk factor for delivering an SGA baby.
We had 15 participants who were missing some of the maternal characteristics required for accurate assessment of SGA customisation. However, since only two participants were missing birthweight data, we performed an additional sensitivity analysis and imputed the mean value from the cohort for the missing maternal parameter and recalculated the customised birth centile. This did not change our results significantly. Finally, our customised centiles and coefficients for the various maternal characteristics were based on USA-based population data, as there has not yet been a Canadian standard developed for calculating customised centiles. However, the distribution of the ethnicity of our cohort fits best with the US data set (ie, coefficient for the Latin American population available) rather than the European or Australian coefficients.
Biological plausibility for gestational exposure to SDB and low birth weight has already been demonstrated in rat models of gestational intermittent hypoxia where asymmetrical growth restriction in addition to overall reduced birth weights have been demonstrated.13 ,14 Our clinical data are consistent with these findings and also demonstrate that objective PSG diagnosis of SDB, rather than symptom-based assessments, are linked with an increased risk of delivering infants that are SGA, suggesting that the use of objective-based measurements of maternal SDB is important for future studies. Our results highlight that SDB, although prevalent in this cohort, is overall mild in severity, similar to what other studies in pregnancy and SDB have observed.45 Despite this, the mild degree of SDB is associated with adverse fetal outcomes. Thus, the use of routine ambulatory sleep studies, which largely depend on oxygen desaturation events rather than arousals, may not detect the large majority of SDB in pregnancy. However, future work is still necessary to compare the accuracy and practical issues in performing ambulatory versus in-laboratory PSG in pregnancy. Finally, to further understand the causal nature of the relationship between maternal SDB and the delivery of SGA infants, interventional trials involving treatment of maternal SDB with CPAP will be needed.
The authors thank the sleep technologists, Chris Brookes, Marcel Severe and Thao linh Dang for their assistance in setting up the sleep recordings. The authors also thank Audree Janelle-Montcalm, Romy-Leigh McMaster and Isabelle Krauss for their assistance with data management from the parent IRNPQEO cohort. The authors thank Victoria Mery for helping review sleep studies. The authors also thank the research participants in this study.
Contributors Conception and design: SP, IM and RJK. Acquisition of data: SP, IM, AO, LL, FS, WF and RJK. Analysis and interpretation of data: SP, IM, GS, AB, RJK. Drafting, revising and critical revision for intellectual content and final approval of the version to be published: SP, IM, LL, AO, FS, WF, FA, EB, RG, GS, AB, KS, RJK. All authors are in agreement to be accountable for the work presented in the manuscript.
Funding Supported by: IRNPQEO: Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) (Grant Ref. No. CRI 88413); SGA substudy: CIHR Sleep and Circadian Rhythm Grant Ref. No.104728, in partnership with Canadian Lung Association and the Fonds de recherche du Québec—Santé (FRQS).
Competing interests None declared.
Ethics approval McGill University Health Centre, Le Centre hospitalier universitaire Sainte-Justine, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.