Article Text

Download PDFPDF

S58 TB co-infection is associated with poor survival among HIV infected patients in england and wales
  1. D Zenner1,
  2. S Conti1,
  3. Z Yin1,
  4. M Kall1,
  5. M Kruijshaar2,
  6. B Rice1,
  7. M Lipman1,
  8. A Pozniak3,
  9. I Abubakar1,
  10. V Delpech1
  1. 1Centre for Infectious Disease Surveillance and Control Public Health England, London, UK
  2. 2Erasmus University, Rotterdam, Netherlands
  3. 3Chelsea and Westminster Hospital, London, UK


Introduction Tuberculosis (TB) rates in the UK are amongst the highest in Western Europe and HIV-TB co-infection (HIV-TB) contributes significantly to the burden of TB in the UK. Globally, HIV-TB is associated with significant morbidity and mortality, in particular where there is delayed diagnosis. Analysis of setting-specific survival can inform local healthcare policy. Here we report the outcome of individuals diagnosed with HIV in the UK, with particular emphasis on TB co-infection.

Methodology We examined deaths among a retrospective national cohort of adults (15 years +) diagnosed with HIV infection between 2000–2008 linked to the national TB databases and death records from the Office of National Statistics to mid-2010. Hazard ratios (HR) estimates using uni- and multi-variable Cox regression modelling were calculated to compare all-cause and AIDS-specific mortality by key demographic and clinical markers.

Results A total of 1,880 (4.3%) deaths were observed among 44,050 HIV-diagnosed adults during 149,663 person-years of follow-up. 3,188 (7.2%) adults developed TB and HIV-TB cases accounted for 341 (18.1%) of all deaths of whom 270 (79.2%) were late presenters (CD4<200 at HIV diagnosis). One year mortality after HIV diagnosis was 45% overall and greater among HIV-TB cases (54%) and those with low CD4 counts at diagnosis (69% for CD4<50). TB co-infection and a low CD4 count at HIV diagnosis significantly increased the hazard of all-cause mortality. In the fully adjusted model, the highest HR was among adults with extrapulmonary TB and pulmonary TB cases with CD4 count <100 at diagnosis (figure 1). The Cox model of AIDS-specific mortality showed similar findings, albeit with increased effect size. Increasing age, female sex, UK country of birth, heterosexual route of exposure to HIV and other AIDS conditions were also associated with poor survival. Antiretroviral therapy (ART) was protective, even if interrupted.

Abstract S58 Figure 1

Multivariable Cox regression model for all cause mortality in persons living with HIV diagnosed in the UK, 2000–2009. Cox regression model for all-cause mortality. There was significant interaction of TB co-infection, CD4 count at diagnosis and site of TB disease–the strata are therefore displayed separately. Dots denote point estimates for hazard ratios for all cause mortality; bars denote 95% confidence intervals. The model was also adjusted for age, sex, region of birth, and probable route of exposure (not displayed here, as effect sizes are moderate and to keep fewer categories). Abbreviations: PTB–pulmonary TB, ETB–extrapulmonary TB, ARVT–Antiretroviral Therapy. The baseline patient is characterised, as a 25–34 year-old UK-born MSM who has never been on ARV, is not TB co-infected and has a CD4 count of 350 or above.

Discussion Despite the availability of effective ART and TB screening and treatment, we observed high death rates among a large national HIV cohort associated with late diagnosis and TB infection. The findings highlight the on-going need for expanded HIV testing and increased TB case finding among HIV diagnosed adults to ensure appropriate and early treatment initiation for both conditions.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.