Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
The airway epithelium, which is exposed to antigens and microbes throughout respiration, provides an enormous and delicate interface with the external environment. In major conducting airways the epithelium is covered by surface liquid, which includes an overlying mucous layer onto which inhaled particles are trapped. The physical defence mechanisms of the airway epithelium include the mucociliary escalator and complex structures known as tight junctions which control paracellular transport of inhaled material. In response to immunological challenge, epithelial cell surfaces produce antimicrobial chemicals (such as surfactants and defensins), cytokines (particularly type I and type III interferons) and chemokines following activation of their pattern recognition receptors, including Toll-like receptors (TLRs). This leads to recruitment of immune cells including dendritic cells, T cells and B cells.
Given the speed, complexity and specificity of these responses, it is likely that, in an environment full of antigens such as the lung, epithelial surfaces will have developed mechanisms to inhibit inflammation, as has already been demonstrated for the microbe-rich milieu of the gut.1 Although it has been recognised for some time that the airway epithelium plays an important role in generating danger signals upon immunological challenge, we need to update these concepts to recognise the importance of this interface in protecting the host from unwanted responses to innocuous environmental agents. Data are now emerging which suggest that, in health, airway epithelial cells (AECs) play a critical role in regulating local immunological homeostasis. The study by Wang et al published in this issue of Thorax provides an important contribution to this body of evidence (see page 283).2
The diverse array of receptors, including TLRs, present on AECs enables them to respond to incoming allergens, micro-organisms, particulate material and initiate appropriate immunological responses. However, it is clear that TLRs cannot distinguish between pathogenic and harmless (but nonetheless immunogenic) stimuli. To protect the host from premature death due to chronic airway inflammation, other mechanisms must be invoked. These might include the ability of epithelial cells to control pattern recognition receptor sensitivity and organ-specific mechanisms to regulate immunity.3 There is some evidence for the first of these regulatory processes in the airways and the gut, where epithelial cells demonstrate ligand-dependent differences in TLR activation which correlate with differences in responses to whole organisms.4 5 Regulatory processes downstream of TLR activation also operate differently in different organs, suppressing inflammation in the lungs compared with organs such as the spleen where the environment is normally sterile.6
In addressing organ-specific regulation of immune responses, the study by Wang et al showed that dendritic cell-induced T cell proliferation was profoundly inhibited in a dose-dependent manner by co-culture with AECs. Experiments suggested that these effects of AECs were predominantly dependent on cell-to-cell contact, with limited effect of soluble factors, and seemed to be partially mediated by transforming growth factor β (TGFβ). Importantly, the experiments showed that the AECs acted directly on the T cells. Another recent study by Mayer et al7 which has addressed these regulatory processes showed that human bronchial epithelial cells inhibited secretion of tumour necrosis factor α (TNFα) and interleukin-12 (IL12) by monocytes, macrophages and dendritic cells, and transfer of supernatant from epithelial cell cultures caused almost as much inhibition as co-culture of cells. Mayer et al, in similar experiments to those of Wang et al, demonstrated a direct inhibitory effect of AECs on T lymphocyte proliferation, partly mediated by secretion of TGFβ.7
This regulation of the proinflammatory capacity of innate immune cells is much more than induction of passive “anergy”. While in the experiments by Wang et al co-culture inhibited the production of many T cell cytokines (interferon (IFN)γ, IL5, IL17, TNFα), it increased the production of others (granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), thymic stromal lymphopoietin (TSLP)). TSLP is a novel, epithelial derived cytokine, which induces dendritic cell mediated Th2 differentiation. Mayer et al showed increased expression of arginase-1 (a marker enzyme of alternative activation by dendritic cells) and IL10 by epithelial cell-conditioned dendritic cells. Both reports also showed that the inhibitory effects of AECs were associated with an increase in the proportion of regulatory T cells, including Tr1 and Foxp3+, and increased numbers of Th17 cells. Taken together, these two studies show that, in the lung—as in the gut1—organ-specific stromal cells regulate the local immune response.
With this profound downregulation of inflammatory responses by epithelial cells, how are the innate immune cells able to respond appropriately to infection? Both groups tested this, but in different ways. Mayer et al showed slightly downregulated secretion of TGFβ in epithelial cells stimulated with Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Respiratory viruses, which are major triggers of airway inflammation, primarily target AECs for infection. Wang et al showed that infection of epithelial cells with respiratory syncytial virus 24 h before addition of the dendritic cell/T cell co-culture reduced T cell inhibition in proportion to the infectious dose. This effect could, in part, be mimicked by some TLR ligands (TLR3 and TLR4, but not TLR9), which suggested that, during viral infection of AECs, it is activation of these pathways that reduces their inhibition of T cells. Following viral infection, AECs produce type I interferons which induce a range of antiviral proteins which limit viral replication and induce AEC apoptosis. In RSV bronchiolitis there is extensive apoptosis and necrosis of AECs which slough off and contribute to small airways obstruction. Wang et al suggest that epithelial cell destruction causes not only physical problems, but further contributes to airway inflammation by releasing the epithelial cell layer from its immunoregulatory capacity.
What are the implications of these findings for the understanding of immune responses to respiratory viral infections in human disease? We know that, in the airways of infants with respiratory syncytial virus bronchiolitis, there is massive production of proinflammatory cytokines8 9 and chemokines10 11 and recruitment of inflammatory cells.12 It is difficult in clinical studies which use bronchoalveolar lavage to assess the relative contribution of AECs and recruited inflammatory cells to cytokine and chemokine production in the airways. However, indirect evidence, such as comparing the amounts of mRNA for these mediators in the cell pellet (which does not contain viable epithelial cells) with protein detected in the supernatant, suggests that even several days after the initiation of lower airway infection, AECs are actively producing inflammatory mediators.11 It is not clear whether the massive inflammation observed in the airways of infants with viral bronchiolitis represents an appropriate and necessary response to infection, or whether it signifies local immune dysregulation which enhances disease in these infants.13
Dysregulation of local immune responses following respiratory viral infection has been shown in asthma. Exacerbations of asthma are frequently initiated by common cold viruses, most commonly rhinoviruses. Infection of asthmatic AECs with rhinoviruses, compared to normal AECs, has shown that the former have limited ability to produce IFNβ and IFNγ.14 15 This results in impaired apoptotic responses and increased viral replication which was reversed by exogenous IFNβ.14 This type I interferon deficiency is highly correlated with severity of asthma exacerbations.15
The work of these two groups will lead to revisions of current concepts and provide important pointers for further research into the role of AECs in local immune regulation. These investigators have correctly redirected our attention to what happens in normal healthy epithelial cells so that we can understand better the consequences of releasing professional immune cells from inhibition by AECs. If—as the work by Mayer et al suggests—these findings are replicated in human cells, in diseases such as asthma is there dysregulation of the homeostatic responses? Do aberrations in the delicate homeostatic control mechanisms result in over-exuberant inflammatory responses to infection which manifest as severe viral bronchiolitis or pneumonia? Is there maturation of these responses in early life when respiratory viral infections are frequent and symptomatic? We are beginning to understand that, in health, the airway epithelium is like a duck—calm on the surface but paddling furiously underneath.
Competing interests: None.