Background: Patterns of wheezing during early childhood may indicate differences in aetiology and prognosis of respiratory illnesses. Improved characterisation of wheezing phenotypes could lead to the identification of environmental influences on the development of asthma and airway diseases in predisposed individuals.
Methods: Data collected on wheezing at seven time points from birth to 7 years from 6265 children in a longitudinal birth cohort (the ALSPAC study) were analysed. Latent class analysis was used to assign phenotypes based on patterns of wheezing. Measures of atopy, airway function (forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1), mid forced expiratory flow (FEF25-75)) and bronchial responsiveness were made at 7–9 years of age.
Results: Six phenotypes were identified. The strongest associations with atopy and airway responsiveness were found for intermediate onset (18 months) wheezing (OR for atopy 8.36, 95% CI 5.2 to 13.4; mean difference in dose response to methacholine 1.76, 95% CI 1.41 to 2.12 %FEV1 per μmol, compared with infrequent/never wheeze phenotype). Late onset wheezing (after 42 months) was also associated with atopy (OR 6.6, 95% CI 4.7 to 9.4) and airway responsiveness (mean difference 1.61, 95% CI 1.37 to 1.85 %FEV1 per μmol). Transient and prolonged early wheeze were not associated with atopy but were weakly associated with increased airway responsiveness and persistent wheeze had intermediate associations with these outcomes.
Conclusions: The wheezing phenotypes most strongly associated with atopy and airway responsiveness were characterised by onset after age 18 months. This has potential implications for the timing of environmental influences on the initiation of atopic wheezing in early childhood.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Asthma is a complex heterogeneous disease comprising a number of discrete phenotypes, such that the term “asthma” has recently been called into question.1 Cohort studies followed to adulthood have reported that more severe childhood wheezing phenotypes are less likely to remit in later life.2–4 Pulmonary function abnormalities associated with persistent wheezing become established during early childhood and track to adult life, suggesting that early life exposures are critical in determining the onset and natural history of wheezing illnesses.3 5 An improved understanding of these phenotypes is therefore of fundamental importance to studies of risk factors for asthma and wheezing illnesses in children.
In a seminal report based on the Tucson Children’s Respiratory Study, Martinez and colleagues proposed three patterns of wheezing during the first 6 years of life6 leading to the concepts of transient early wheezing in the first 3 years, non-atopic wheezing in the preschool years and IgE-mediated wheeze or asthma.7 Although these have served as useful models of wheezing phenotypes in early childhood, there is evidence that phenotypes diverge earlier than 3 years8 and a recent report described variations in immune responses within seemingly homogeneous phenotypes of IgE-mediated asthma.9 We used a novel symptom-driven approach to define wheezing phenotypes using repeat measurements of wheeze during the first 7 years of childhood in a large population-based birth cohort study, the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC). We investigated associations of these phenotypes with physician-diagnosed asthma and objectively measured atopy and airway function at age 7–9 years.
ALSPAC is a longitudinal population-based birth cohort study that recruited 14 541 pregnant women resident in Avon, UK with expected dates of delivery 1 April 1991 to 31 December 1992. There were 14 062 liveborn children. The study protocol has been described previously10 11 and further details are shown on the ALSPAC website (http://www.alspac.bris.ac.uk).
At 6, 18, 30, 42, 54, 69 and 81 months after birth, study mothers were sent a self-completion questionnaire about the health of their child. They were asked to report the occurrence of 15 common symptoms, including wheezing, in the previous 12 months (6 months for the initial questionnaire) and, if present, whether they consulted a doctor. In a separate section they were asked whether in the past 12 months (6 months in the first questionnaire) their child had “wheezing with whistling on the chest when (s)he breathed”. At 91 months of age mothers were asked in a separate questionnaire to report if a physician had ever told them that their child had asthma.
The atopic status of the children was determined at 7–8 years of age by skin prick test responses to a panel of up to 12 common allergens including house dust mite (Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus), mixed grasses and cat (ALK; Abelló, Hoersholm, Denmark). Sensitisation to one of these three allergens has been shown to identify 95% of all sensitised children in this population.12 A positive response was defined as a mean weal diameter of ⩾2 mm with an absent response to negative control solution, and atopy was defined as a positive response to one or more of house dust mite, cat or grass pollen. Mothers were asked to report a personal history of asthma or allergy in a questionnaire administered during pregnancy.
At 8–9 years of age, lung function was measured by spirometry (Vitalograph 2120, Maids Moreton, UK) according to American Thoracic Society criteria.13 Flow-volume curves were reviewed by one respiratory physician (JH) to ensure adherence to standards, resulting in the rejection of 338 (4.6%) measurements and the correction of 883 (11.5%) where the automated programme had selected an inappropriate curve. Each variable (forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1), forced vital capacity (FVC) and mid forced expiratory flow (FEF25–75)) was converted to sex-, age- and height-adjusted standard deviation units.14 Airway responsiveness to methacholine was measured using the method of Yan et al15 and expressed for each subject as the dose-response slope of FEV1 (percentage decline from baseline) per μmol methacholine.
Wheeze was defined as present if the response to either question about wheezing was “yes” and absent if the response to both was “no”. All other combinations were classed as missing (1.3%). As there were two levels of response to questions about wheeze at seven time points, there were 27 = 128 different patterns of wheezing possible. Therefore, to derive phenotypes with similar wheezing patterns over time, we used latent class analysis. This is a statistical method for finding subtypes of related cases (latent classes) from multivariable categorical data (in this case, responses to wheezing questions across seven time points). Briefly, individuals were clustered into a number of discrete latent classes (phenotypes) on the basis of the pattern of responses to each of the wheezing questions. The latent class model aims to determine the minimum number of latent classes that describe the observed patterns of responses in the data.16 A full description of the latent class analysis used in this study and methods used to evaluate the best fitting model are shown in the online supplement. The posterior probability of each individual belonging to a particular phenotype was estimated and, from these data, the estimated prevalence of wheeze at each time point was calculated for each phenotype.
Children with complete reports of wheezing at all seven time points were included in the analyses. Logistic and linear regression was used to estimate associations of phenotype membership with physician-diagnosed asthma and objective measurements of atopy, lung function and bronchial responsiveness in mid childhood and with maternal self-reported asthma and allergy. As latent class analysis is robust to missing data and misclassification of data items such as faulty recall of wheezing episodes, we repeated all analyses in children who returned questionnaires at two or more time points.
All analyses were done using MPlus 4.1 software (Muthén & Muthén, Los Angeles, 2006).
Of 11 678 children with reports of wheezing on at least two occasions, 6265 (54%) had complete data. The characteristics of the study population are shown in table 1. Children with complete data were less likely to come from socially deprived backgrounds and had lower prevalence of reported wheezing in early childhood than children with missing data.
Comparison of Bayesian information criteria (BIC; see online supplement) suggested that a model with six phenotypes provided the best fit (BIC from models with 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 phenotypes were 34709, 34357, 34304, 34275 and 34285, respectively). Bootstrap likelihood ratio tests (BLRT) suggested a further improvement in fit comparing models with seven and eight phenotypes in cases with complete data only; analyses of data from children with at least two measures of wheezing from 6 to 81 months suggested—based on both BIC and BLRT—that a six-phenotype model provided the best fit. We therefore selected the more parsimonious solution and based further analyses on six-phenotype models for both datasets.
The estimated prevalence of wheezing at each time point in the six phenotypes is shown in fig 1. Hereafter, we describe the phenotypes as follows:
1: Never/infrequent wheeze (59.3% of children) had approximately 10% prevalence of wheezing at 6 months with declining prevalence of sporadic wheeze thereafter and included subjects (76.5% of this category) who never reported wheeze.
2: Transient early wheeze (16.3%) had 50–60% prevalence up to 18 months, declining to low prevalence from 42 months.
3: Prolonged early wheeze (8.9%) had a peak prevalence of around 65% at 30 months, declining to low prevalence from 69 months.
4: Intermediate onset wheeze (2.7%) had a low prevalence up to 18 months, rising rapidly to high prevalence from age 42 months.
5: Late onset wheeze (6.0%) had approximately 20% prevalence up to 42 months, rising to 50% or higher prevalence thereafter.
6: Persistent wheeze (6.9%) had 65% prevalence at 6 months with approximately 90% prevalence thereafter.
Patterns of wheezing were similar in 11 678 children with missing data (see fig E1 in online supplement).
Association of wheezing phenotypes with atopy and parental asthma/allergy
Table 2 shows associations of wheezing phenotypes with skin test responses at age 7–8 years. Intermediate onset wheeze, late onset wheeze and persistent wheeze were strongly associated with atopy. Neither of the early wheezing phenotypes was associated with atopy or specific allergen sensitisation. Intermediate onset wheezing showed the strongest associations with atopy and with sensitisation to cat and house dust mite (D pteronyssinus) allergens. Late onset wheezing was also strongly associated with cat and house dust sensitisation and had the strongest association with grass pollen sensitisation.
Maternal self-reported asthma and allergy were positively associated with all wheezing phenotypes compared with infrequent wheeze (table 3). The strongest association with both maternal phenotypes was seen with persistent wheeze.
Association of wheezing phenotypes with asthma and lung function
All wheezing phenotypes were associated with physician-diagnosed asthma by age 91 months compared with the never/infrequent wheeze phenotype. The proportion of subjects with physician-diagnosed asthma and odds ratios (OR) (95% confidence interval (CI)) were as follows: transient early wheeze 8.5%, OR 2.5 (95% CI 1.5 to 4.1); prolonged early wheeze 36%, OR 14.9 (95% CI 10.7 to 20.7); intermediate onset wheeze 92.8%, OR 326 (95% CI 138 to 770); late onset wheeze 76.2%, OR 85 (95% CI 56 to 128); persistent wheeze 92.1%, OR 308 (95% CI 186 to 510).
Compared with the late onset phenotype, the intermediate onset phenotype was associated with a higher prevalence of doctor-diagnosed asthma (OR 3.9, 95% CI 1.1 to 13.2). Similarly, compared with the transient early phenotype, the prolonged early phenotype had an OR of asthma at 91 months of 6.0 (95% CI 3.5 to 10.3), reflecting the marked difference in prevalence of doctor-diagnosed asthma (9% and 36%, respectively) in the two groups.
Table 4 shows associations of wheezing phenotypes with lung function and airway responsiveness at 8–9 years of age. All phenotypes were associated with decrements of FEV1 and FEF25–75 and increased airway responsiveness compared with never/infrequent wheeze. The greatest decrements were associated with prolonged early, intermediate onset and persistent wheezing. Airway responsiveness was highest in the intermediate and late onset phenotypes.
Compared with late onset wheezing, the intermediate onset phenotype was associated with decrements of FEV1 and FEF25–75 of 0.33 (95% CI 0.10 to 0.55) and 0.28 (95% CI 0.05 to 0.52) standard deviations, respectively. There was also a decrement in mid-expiratory flow (mean difference for FEF25–75 −0.22 SD units (95% CI −0.34 to −0.11) in the prolonged early wheezing group compared with the transient early wheezing group.
Never wheeze versus infrequent wheeze
As 2979/3896 subjects (76.5%) assigned to the never/infrequent wheeze phenotype had never reported wheeze, the associations with objective outcomes of these children were compared with the 917 subjects assigned to this group who reported at least one episode of wheeze. The never wheeze group had higher FEV1 (mean difference 0.14 SD units (95% CI 0.05 to 0.22)) and FEF25–75 (mean difference 0.18 SD units (95% CI 0.10 to 0.27)) and lower airway responsiveness (−0.30 percentage FEV1 per μmol methacholine (95% CI −0.13 to −0.47)) than those with at least one reported episode of wheeze. There were no differences in the prevalence of atopy or individual skin prick test responses between these two groups.
Associations of wheezing phenotypes with other outcomes in children with missing data
The associations of wheezing phenotypes with maternal asthma and with later childhood outcomes in 11 678 children who returned at least two questionnaires on wheezing are shown in tables E3–E5 in the online supplement. These gave very similar results to the analyses based on children with complete data on wheezing between 6 and 81 months of age.
Using data on reported wheezing collected at frequent intervals during the first 7 years in a large population-based birth cohort, we have identified six childhood wheezing phenotypes and quantified their associations with objective measures of atopy and lung function in mid-childhood. Two of these phenotypes have not been described previously. Prolonged early wheeze (around 9% of children) was characterised by wheezing from age 6 to 54 months with low prevalence from age 69 months onwards. It was not associated with aeroallergen sensitisation but was associated with increased airway responsiveness and lower lung function at ages 8–9 years compared with the never/infrequent wheeze phenotype. Intermediate onset wheeze (around 2.5% of children) had onset between ages 18 and 42 months. This phenotype was characterised by the strongest association with atopy (particularly skin prick sensitivity to D pteronyssinus and cat allergen), lower lung function and higher levels of airway responsiveness compared with the never/infrequent wheeze phenotype. Such associations (represented figuratively in table 5) may reveal differing aetiological or environmental influences on the inception of asthma in young children.
Although the phenotypes identified here have similarities to previously reported patterns of early childhood wheezing, there were differences in their associations with objective outcomes. In the Tucson study, children with persistent and late onset wheeze had the strongest associations with atopy and those with persistent and transient early wheeze had the greatest decrements of lung function at age 6 and 11 years,5 with only persistent wheeze being positively associated with increased airway responsiveness at 11 years.17 Our results challenge these paradigms in that intermediate onset wheezing was most strongly associated with atopy and airway responsiveness in our study, although it should be noted that this pattern would have been included in the persistent wheeze phenotype as defined by the Tucson group. Persistent wheeze in the present study was less strongly associated with atopy than intermediate or late onset wheeze, but was associated with similar lung function deficits to intermediate onset wheeze, suggesting that persistent wheeze may represent a mixture of structural airway abnormalities associated with early onset wheezing and atopic wheeze that develops during early childhood.
In order to interpret the relevance of these findings to the heterogeneity of early childhood wheezing, it is necessary to appreciate the advantages and limitations of the latent class method used to identify the phenotypes in this study. As the term “latent classes” implies, these are not directly observed phenomena but were constructed post hoc on the basis of the pattern of responses to wheezing over a fixed number of observation periods. These methods are therefore not applicable to predicting the natural history of wheezing in individual subjects. Each child was assigned a probability of membership of each class based on their overall wheezing history. As shown in table E1 in the online supplement, some children had a high probability of membership of a single class while the assignment of others was less certain. This becomes increasingly evident in analyses including children with some missing observations of wheeze. Children with clear patterns of reported wheezing, such as those who always or never wheezed, had the highest probability of belonging to a single phenotype and therefore contributed the greatest weight to analyses of associations of these phenotypes with other outcomes. The advantage of the latent class approach is that the phenotypes were not constrained by prespecified notions of their number or nature; these were determined by the patterns observed in the data. Clear and interpretable associations of the different phenotypes with physician-diagnosed asthma and with objective measures of atopy and lung function at ages 7–9 years confirmed the utility of the approach. However, we acknowledge that the question of whether these phenotypes represent discrete pathophysiological entities cannot be resolved by the present analysis. For instance, it is conceivable that prolonged and transient early wheezing represents different severities of the same broad phenotype, with the more severe phenotype being associated with longer duration of wheeze and poorer prognosis. Future analyses of associations of these derived phenotypes with early life exposures that may contribute to their aetiology will help to address some of these issues.
An advantage of our study compared with previous cohort studies of the natural history of wheezing is its larger size, which allows investigation of associations of wheezing phenotypes with different measures of atopy and lung function, despite the fact that some phenotypes represented relatively small proportions of children. For comparison, the Tuscon Study reported on 826 children during the first 6 years,6 the Dunedin study on 613 subjects with complete respiratory data at 9–26 years,3 the Perth study of infant lung function reported outcomes at 11 years in 183 infants18 and a cohort of 2860 infants in Perth reported on asthma to age 6 years.19
There were also a number of limitations of our data. In common with most cohort studies,20 loss to follow-up was greater in children from more socially deprived backgrounds. Given known associations of social deprivation with early childhood wheezing,21 it is likely that children excluded because of missing data had a higher proportion of transient early wheezing than those included. We addressed this problem more comprehensively than previous cohort studies because we found similar results when we repeated latent class analyses using 11 678 children with two or more observations of wheeze.
The wheeze questionnaire that was devised for the ALSPAC study in 1991 contains similar questions to the ISAAC questionnaire now in common use.22 Care was taken to resolve discrepancies in responses to different questions about wheezing in the present study. However, it has been reported that parental-reported wheezing in early life is imprecise23 and correlates poorly with objective observations24 or with wheeze assessed by health professionals.25 Reassuringly, we found extremely strong associations (ORs up to 326) between wheezing phenotypes and physician-diagnosed asthma reported at age 91 months. Because we had up to seven observations of wheeze, and because the latent class approach allows for misclassification, lack of reliability of parental reporting of wheeze appears not to have been a problem in this study.
We did not have reliable data on treatment for wheeze in early life, although recent studies have suggested that treatment with inhaled corticosteroids in infancy does not alter the natural history of wheezing illnesses in children.26 27 However, it is conceivable that treatment suppressed symptoms of wheeze completely in some subjects, which may have biased reporting towards those with more severe symptoms. Alternatively, suppression of symptoms by treatment with inhaled steroids may have contributed to misclassification of phenotypes that were based on parental-reported wheeze. As this is likely to have affected those phenotypes with the strongest associations with doctor-diagnosed asthma, we would have expected such an effect to attenuate differences between these and other phenotypic groups rather than to lead to spurious associations with objective outcomes. We plan to investigate markers of severity within phenotypes in future studies.
Our finding that the intermediate and late onset phenotypes had the strongest associations with atopy is consistent with a critical window of immunological responses28 during which environmental influences, such as allergens29 30 or viral respiratory infections,31 interact with genetic variants in immune responsiveness to influence the risk of developing asthma and allergy.32 The association of late onset wheezing with grass pollen sensitisation may also represent a complex interplay of environmental exposures and genetic predisposition with the later onset of symptoms related to seasonal as opposed to ubiquitous allergen exposure.
Transient early wheezing has been associated with reduced lung function soon after birth, and there is evidence from several studies that such deficits are likely to improve partially in later childhood, although may continue to track below normal values.5 18 33 Early postnatal measurements were not available in our study but, based on this literature, it seems plausible that early decrements of lung function were associated with the three early onset wheezing phenotypes which were less strongly associated with atopy and airway responsiveness than later onset wheezing. Reduced lung function soon after birth is associated with asthma34 and airway responsiveness35 in later childhood. Our finding of mid-childhood lung function decrements in children with prolonged early and persistent wheezing could reflect persistence of developmental airway abnormalities, but is also consistent with allergenic or non-allergenic postnatal exposures aggravating existing structural airway abnormalities in subgroups of early onset wheeze. The importance of such decrements in mid-childhood is that, once established, they are likely to persist to adulthood.3 5
In summary, the childhood wheezing phenotypes most strongly associated with atopy and airway responsiveness in our study were characterised by onset of wheezing after the age of 18 months. Wheezing onset soon after birth was not associated with atopy or airway responsiveness except when it persisted to later childhood. Persistent wheeze may represent a complex phenotype comprising different pathophysiological components encompassing early structural or functional airway changes modified by inflammatory processes during early childhood. Environmental influences on the initiation of atopic wheezing or which modify existing wheezing phenotypes are likely to have a major influence during the first years after birth. The search for modifiable factors that account for the rise in asthma and allergic diseases in industrialised countries36 should focus on interactions between genes and environment during this critical period. The availability of early environmental data in the ALSPAC cohort will enable these associations to be examined in relation to the phenotypes described here.
The authors are extremely grateful to all the families who took part in this study, the midwives for their help in recruiting them, and the whole ALSPAC team which includes interviewers, computer and laboratory technicians, clerical workers, research scientists, volunteers, managers, receptionists and nurses. The authors are grateful to Professor Graham Dunn and Professor Andrew Pickles for helpful advice on statistical analyses, and Professor George Davey Smith for helpful comments on previous drafts of the manuscript.
Funding: This research was specifically funded by a grant from Asthma UK to establish a research network of UK asthma birth cohorts (the STELAR network). The skin prick tests were funded by a grant from the British Lung Foundation and the measurements of lung function and airway responsiveness were supported by a grant from the UK Medical Research Council. SOS is an Asthma UK Senior Research Fellow. The UK Medical Research Council, the Wellcome Trust and the University of Bristol provide core support for ALSPAC.
Competing interests: None.
Ethics approval: Ethics approval for all aspects of data collection was obtained from the ALSPAC Law and Ethics Committee (IRB 00003312).
This publication is the work of the authors and JH and JACS will serve as guarantors for the contents of the paper.
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.