Article Text

Download PDFPDF

A step forward in the evidence-based treatment of opportunist mycobacteria
  1. Chest Clinic
  2. Blackburn Royal Infirmary
  3. Blackburn
  4. Lancs BB2 3LR, UK
  5. pandpormerod{at}

    Statistics from

    While the treatment of Mycobacterium tuberculosis is firmly based on multiple controlled clinical trials in various settings1 2 and meet the criteria for ‘A’ category recommendations,3 the management of opportunist mycobacteria (mycobacteria other than tuberculosis (MOTT), non-tuberculous mycobacteria, environmental mycobacteria, atypical mycobacteria) is much less so. When the Joint Tuberculosis Committee of the British Thoracic Society reviewed the evidence base for the treatment of this group of organisms in HIV negative persons for their 2000 treatment guidelines,4 only the treatment recommended for M kansasii was based on a prospective controlled study.5 The treatment recommendations for the other common opportunist mycobacteria causing respiratory disease in HIV negative persons, usually secondary to underlying chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or structural lung disease—M malmoense, M avium intracellulare, and M xenopi—were largely based on retrospective non-controlled studies.6-11

    One of the other difficulties with treatment in opportunist mycobacteria is the fact that, unlike with M tuberculosis where the drug susceptibility data have to be scrupulously followed,1 the drug susceptibility data using in vitro testing may not correlate at all with the clinical response to treatment. Studies have shown synergy between rifampicin and ethambutol and for other drugs in opportunist mycobacteria which had been reported as resistant to these drugs individually on in vitro testing.12-14

    The results of the first randomised trial of regimens of rifampicin and ethambutol with or without isoniazid reported in this issue ofThorax 15 give a basis on which treatment recommendations can be made, but also raises further questions. The results of the two reported regimens are as good as those using 5–6 drugs and much better tolerated.6-11They also confirm that drug susceptibility tests using the standard modal resistance technique16 do not predict clinical or bacteriological response. There are some differences between the regimens and the organisms depending on which end point is selected. Although for individual organisms fewer deaths occurred with the rifampicin/ethambutol regimen, this only reached significance when the results for all three organisms were combined. Using the outcome variable of treatment failure/relapse, the rifampicin/isoniazid/ethambutol combination is superior, particularly for M avium intracellulare. The “bottom line” message appears to be that rifampicin/ethambutol are best forM malmoense and M xenopi; because of the possibility of higher mortality, the addition of isoniazid should be reserved for M avium intracellulare which has failed to become culture negative.

    While giving data from which to consider treatment recommendations, the study also shows relapse/failure rates of 10–28%, outcomes which are much worse than for M tuberculosis.Better regimens are needed and the results of the ongoing study using macrolides or quinolones as well as rifampicin/ethambutol will be eagerly awaited to see if these give better outcomes. The authors also raise the question as to whether individual drug susceptibility data should be given when these opportunist mycobacteria are isolated because of the lack of correlation with clinical outcome, and wonder whether either no data or only data concerning susceptibility to drug combinations should be reported. The feasibility of the latter suggestion would need discussion with the United Kingdom Mycobacterium reference centres and units and results in terms of prediction of outcome would need to be validated.


    View Abstract

    Request Permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.