Table 1

Description of the included studies

First authorCountryYearSubject numberMean/median age (years)Male patients (%)BCG rate (%)TST cut-off (mm)Patients on IST (%)IGRA methodID rate of IGRA (%)
AndrisaniItaly20139239.6501.15/1076QFT1.1
Arenas MirasSpain20149242.77.62.25/1064.1T-SPOT4.3
Arias-GuillénSpain201420542.350.289.8583QFT T-SPOT2.4*
BartalesiItaly200939854.034.94.15/1078QFT1.2
CasasSpain201121448.549.723.6576.2QFT5.6
CostantinoFrance201356351.04378583.3T-SPOT15.6
HantaTurkey20129040.948.992.2547.8QFTN/A
KwakernaakNetherlands20115650.353.65564.3QFTN/A
LaffitteSwitzerland20095048.070905/1068T-SPOTN/A
MarietteFrance201239245.041.365.7559.7QFT T-SPOT2.8*
Martyn-SimmonsUK20137047.058.664.35/1543QFT T-SPOT4.3*
MatulisUK200814247.95083589QFT5.6
PapayAustria201020836.648.61005/1071.6QFT7.7
SchoepferSwitzerland200816841.049.470.25/1581QFTN/A
ScrivoItaly201211947.031.15.9580.7QFT17.6
WongHong Kong201426543.159.773.1546.6QFT1.5
YilmazTurkey20127838.0997.4550QFT2.6
  • *Study that assessed both QFT and T-SPOT. The lower indeterminate rate is presented here.

  • BCG, Bacillus Calmette–Guérin; ID rate, indeterminate rate; IGRA, interferon γ release assay; IST, immunosuppressive therapy; N/A, not available; QFT, QuantiFERON-TB Gold In-Tube test; TST, tuberculin skin test.