Table 2

Demographic data, asbestos exposure, and multivariate analysis of lung functional parameters according to CT scan abnormalities

Group 1Group 0Group 2p Valuep Value
Pleural plaques*Normal CT scanDiffuse pleural thickeningGroup 1/Group 0Group 0/Group 2
Number of subjects526180241
Gender0.00080.12
 Male, n (%)515 (97.9)1700 (94.3)41 (100)
 Female, n (%)11 (2.1)102 (5.7)
Mean (SD) age (years)64.8 (5.5)62.3 (5.3)65.9 (6.8)<0.0001<0.0001
Smoking status<0.00010.25
 Non-smokers, n (%)81 (15.4)548 (30.4)8 (19.5)
 Ex-smokers, n (%)403 (76.6)1145 (63.5)29 (70.7)
 Smokers, n (%)42 (8.0)109 (6.0)4 (9.8)
Mean (SD) BMI, kg/m227.4 (3.9)27.4 (3.7)27.4 (3.9)0.97051.00
Duration of exposure to asbestos (years)0.00590.26
 1–9, n (%)23 (4.4)111 (6.2)2 (4.9)
 10–19, n (%)40 (7.6)202 (11.2)2 (4.9)
 20–29, n (%)89 (16.9)365 (20.3)7 (17.1)
 30–39, n (%)251 (47.7)752 (41.7)16 (39.0)
 ≥40, n (%)123 (23.4)372 (20.6)14 (34.1)
Cumulative exposure index to asbestos (unit of exposure × years)<0.00010.14
 0–3.4, n (%)66 (12.5)461 (25.6)6 (14.6)
 3.4–17.2, n (%)65 (12.4)385 (21.4)7 (17.1)
 17.2–33.1, n (%)85 (16.2)365 (20.3)9 (21.9)
 33.1–91.9, n (%)110 (20.9)338 (18.8)8 (19.5)
 ≥ 91.9, n (%)200 (38.0)253 (14.0)11 (26.8)
 Mean (SD)110.9 (126.1)47.9 (83.1)81.3 (112.0)
 Median40.020.030.0
Pulmonary function (% predicted FVC, FEV1, FEF25-75, RV and TLC, absolute ratio for FEV1/FVC)§
 FVC, mean (SD)96.4 (17.3)100.4 (16.6)87.7 (20.5)<0.0001<0.0001
 FEV1, mean (SD)96.9 (20.3)101.9 (19.2)85.8 (20.9)<0.001<0.0001
 FEV1/FVC, mean (SD)78.4 (9.3)80.0 (7.9)76.1 (7.2)0.870.04
 FEF25-75, mean (SD)88.9 (36.7)95.9 (35.5)75.9 (35.0)0.080.0019
 FEF25, mean (SD)84.3 (51.9)92.4 (60.5)73.8 (56.2)0.060.06
 FEF50, mean (SD)88.7 (45.4)93.9 (34.2)69.6 (34.0)0.31<0.0001
 FEF75, mean (SD)86.0 (29.8)91.8 (28.7)74.8 (26.7)0.040.001
 RV, mean (SD)108.0 (31.1)109.1 (35.4)91.9 (31.9)0.970.0056
 TLC, mean (SD)98.4 (14.1)101.2 (16.0)88.4 (16.6)0.03<0.0001
  • * Subjects with isolated pleural plaques and subjects with pleural plaques and other abnormalities (except asbestosis and diffuse pleural thickening).

  • Subjects with no CT scan abnormalities.

  • Subjects with diffuse pleural thickening and other abnormalities (except asbestosis).

  • § Adjusting for age, smoking status, BMI, cumulative exposure index (CEI) for asbestos and the centres where pulmonary function tests were conducted.

  • χ2 or Fisher tests.

  • BMI, body mass index; FEF25-75, forced expiratory flow at 25–75% FVC; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1 s; FVC, forced vital capacity; RV, residual volume; TLC, total lung capacity.