Table 3

Effects of ETS exposure on flow measures from cross sectional studies in school aged children: studies not included in meta-analysis

Reference numberFVCFEV1MEFREEFRExposure (refers to current smoking status unless specified)Adjustments3-153
p valuebSEp valuebSEp
value
bSEp valuebSE
 4>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/a?>0.05n/an/aOnly mother smokers vs notAge, ht, sex, wt, fh
 29<0.0001−1.27n/aMother ⩾10/day vs mother non-smokerAge, ht, sex, edu, area, season
 30>0.05∼0n/aEither parent smokes vs neitherAge
 310.05–0.011.1n/a>0.05−0.1n/a0.05–0.01−2.4n/a<0.01−2.6n/aBoth parents smoke vs neither parent smokesAge, ht, sex
 32<0.01−ven/a?>0.05n/an/aPassive smoking (?) vs noneAge, ht, sex, wt, edu, area, gas, smok
 33<0.001−2.43-151 n/aMother smokes vs nobody smokesAge, sex
 34>0.05n/an/a<0.05−ven/a<0.05−ven/aMother smokes vs notEthnic group
 35>0.05+ven/a2 smokers in home vs noneAge, sex, ht
 36>0.05−ven/a0.05–0.01−ven/a0.01–0.001−ven/aMaternal smoking vs noneAge, sex, ht, area
 37>0.05−1.9n/a>0.05−1.9n/a0.01–0.001−6.2n/aSharing a bedroom with an adult smoker vs notAge, sex, ht, wt, school, edu, gas, asthma, fh
 38>0.05+ven/a>0.05−ven/a<0.05−ven/aAt least one parent vs noneAge, race, sex
 39<0.001−ven/a>0.05−ven/a<0.001−ven/aHousehold exposure vs noneUnclear
 40>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/a2 vs 1 vs 0 parents smokeAge, ht, wt, sex, many others
 413-152 >0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/aEither parent smokes vs neitherAge, sex, ht, wt, area, coal stoves
 42>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/aBoth parents smoke vs noneAge, wheeze
 43>0.05n/an/a0.007n/an/aMaternal smoking (10 cigs/day) vs noneAge, sex, ht, wt
 440.638−ven/a0.051−ven/a0.003−ven/a0.040−ven/aMaternal smoking (cigs/day)Age, sex, ht, wt, bwt, area, edu, gas
 450.001−6.6n/aMaternal smoker vs nonAge, sex, ht, area
 463-150 N/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/aPassive smoking (?) vs notAge, sex, possibly ht, wt
 47>0.05n/an/a>0.05n/an/aETS—yes vs noAge,sex,ht,wt
  • 3-150 Boys only presented in whom a reduced pulmonary function was seen if ETS exposed.

  • 3-151 ETS effect of –2.4% was for FEV1/FVC.

  • 3-152 Likely that few mothers smoked. Analyses were carried out separately by area and sex and cooking method.

  • 3-153 Abbreviations: ht = height, wt = weight, fh = family history of asthma or allergy, edu = education of parents, gas = gas cooking, bwt = birth weight