Article Text


M38 Health Professionals’ Views Of Tuberculosis Cohort Audit In North West England
  1. S Wallis1,
  2. K Jehan1,
  3. M Woodhead2,
  4. P Cleary3,
  5. K Dee3,
  6. S Farrow4,
  7. P McMaster5,
  8. C Wake6,
  9. J Walker7,
  10. SB Squire8
  1. 1Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine, Liverpool, UK
  2. 2Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK
  3. 3Public Health England, Liverpool, UK
  4. 4Bolton NHS Trust, Bolton, UK
  5. 5North Manchester General Hospital, Manchester, UK
  6. 6NW TB Audit Coordinator, Liverpool, UK
  7. 7Liverpool Community Health, Liverpool, UK
  8. 8Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine andRoyal Liverpool University Hospital, Liverpool, UK


Introduction and objectives Tuberculosis cohort audit (TBCA) was introduced across the North West in 2012 as recommended by NICE. The approach taken and the outcome measures of the 1,515 TB cases reviewed are presented in a companion abstract. TBCA over a large geographical area has not undergone formal qualitative evaluation in the UK. We conducted a qualitative evaluation to explore perceptions about implementation and impact of TBCA in the North West.

Methods One researcher conducted face to face, semi-structured, recorded interviews between 06/01/14 and14/03/14 with 26 purposively sampled respondents from three groups involved in TBCA: (a) TB nurse specialists; (b) Consultant physicians; (c) Public health practitioners. Transcripts were analysed descriptively and thematically using the Framework Method. Themes were triangulated with eight key informants from the TBCA Steering Group.

Results Four themes were identified:

  1. Preconceptions: Participants were optimistic about the potential of audit to improve practice but worried about time demands and scrutiny from colleagues.

  2. Experience of TBCA: All groups felt engaged and appreciated TBCA. Nurses requested more engagement from consultant colleagues. Fears about time demands and scrutiny were not realised.

  3. Changes as a result of TBCA: Improvements to practice were identified including harmonisation of approaches, increased HIV testing, and improved documentation. TBCA was felt to provide peer support and learning through discussion and a no-blame atmosphere.

  4. Looking Ahead: Suggestionsfor further improvement were captured, such as more in-depth discussion around complex cases. If TBCA were to be discontinued (e.g. because of funding contraints), adverse consequences were predicted: e.g. disappointed and disenfranchised professionals, financial and patient harms.

Conclusions Overall, TBCA in the North West has led to the development of a unique and valuable community of practice. The interchange of experience and ideas across a large number of teams and professionals has enhanced mutual respect between different roles and a shared sense of purpose. TBCA is appreciated by health professionals who participate. Continuing success will require increased engagement of consultant physicians and public health practitioners, a secure an ongoing funding stream and establishment of reporting mechanisms within the new commissioning structures.

Statistics from

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.