Article Text


Combination therapy for exercise intolerance in COPD
  1. R Casaburi
  1. Correspondence to:
    Dr R Casaburi
    Rehabilitation Clinical Trials Center, Los Angeles Biomedical Research Institute at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center, 1124 W Carson Street, Building J4, Torrance, CA 90502, USA; casaburi{at}

Statistics from

New combined approaches to reduce dynamic hyperinflation improve exercise intolerance in patients with COPD

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a miserable disease; exercise intolerance is one of its most troubling symptoms. Moreover, it has recently been discovered that poor exercise tolerance is highly predictive of poor survival. Those who care for these patients are therefore highly motivated to seek ways to ameliorate exercise intolerance. In recent years progress has come from what, at first glance, would seem to be an unlikely quarter. Although research expenditures for this disease are heavily weighted towards cell and molecular biology pursuits, physiological research (considered “old fashioned” in some quarters) has provided solid insights into rational treatment for exercise intolerance.

A key insight is that dynamic hyperinflation is a major mechanism limiting exercise tolerance in patients with COPD. This occurs when the increased metabolic requirements of exercise demand higher levels of pulmonary ventilation. This, in turn, requires that both tidal volume and respiratory rate increase. The patient with COPD is asked to exhale a larger volume in a shorter time, which becomes an impossible task given flow limitation imposed by the increased expiratory airflow resistance. At some point the exhalation cannot be completed in the allotted expiratory time, full exhalation cannot be accomplished, and end expiratory volume increases. Eventually, dynamic hyperinflation leads to end inspiratory lung volumes that approach a limiting value (total lung capacity). As the inspiratory reserve volume shrinks, additional inspiratory volume cannot be achieved without greatly increased elastic work of breathing, since the lung is increasingly on a shallow portion of its pressure-volume curve. Severe dyspnoea results and exercise terminates when this sensation becomes unbearable.


Pulmonary physiologists have been working to develop strategies to lessen dynamic hyperinflation at a given amount of exercise. Logically, approaches that either allow faster exhalation (reduced expiratory airflow resistance) or prolong the time allowed for exhalation (decreased respiratory rate) will allow fuller exhalation, thereby reducing dynamic hyperinflation and improving exercise tolerance. To date, four distinct approaches have been defined that either lower expiratory airflow resistance or slow respiratory rate:

  • Oxygen supplementation.

  • Treatment with bronchodilators.

  • Heliox (79% helium, 21% oxygen).

  • High intensity rehabilitative exercise training.

Oxygen supplementation

Oxygen supplementation reduces carotid body drive and slows respiration at a given level of exercise. Dynamic hyperinflation is reduced and exercise tolerance is substantially prolonged. Increasing inspired oxygen fraction up to roughly 50% confers progressively greater benefits. This occurs even in patients with COPD whose level of exercise desaturation does not meet the usual criteria for oxygen supplementation.1

Treatment with bronchodilators

COPD is now recognised as distinctly not a disease of irreversible airflow obstruction. In a substantial majority of patients with COPD treatment with bronchodilators yields clinically useful improvements in expiratory airflow, allows fuller exhalation in a given period of time, reduces dynamic hyperinflation, and prolongs exercise tolerance. Reduced dynamic hyperinflation accompanied by exercise tolerance improvements has been best demonstrated with long acting anticholinergic agents.2


Heliox (79% helium, 21% oxygen) has a lower density than air and decreases airflow resistance. Breathing heliox lowers expiratory airflow resistance, decreases dynamic hyperinflation, and prolongs exercise tolerance.3

Rehabilitative exercise training

High intensity rehabilitative exercise training has been widely acknowledged to substantially increase exercise tolerance in patients with COPD.4 An important mechanism of the benefits of exercise training has recently been defined.5 As the exercising muscles become more fit, they release less lactic acid at a given level of exercise. Since lactic acid stimulates respiration, after rehabilitative training exercise ventilation is lower, respiration is slowed, and dynamic hyperinflation is reduced.5


If any one of these interventions improves exercise tolerance, it seems logical that a combination of any two (“combination therapy”) would yield even better results. There seems to be a minor competition among physiologically orientated laboratories to see which can demonstrate the effectiveness of these four treatments taken pairwise.

Our laboratory has shown that providing supplemental oxygen (3 l/min by nasal cannula) during a 7 week high intensity rehabilitation programme increased the tolerated work rates of patients during training and enhanced the improvements in exercise tolerance in comparison with COPD patients who trained while breathing room air.6 Patients who before training tolerated an average of 6 minutes of exercise at a given work rate breathing air tolerated an average of 26 minutes at the same work rate while breathing 30% oxygen after an oxygen supplemented training programme. For several participants it was apparent that, after training, their physiological capacity for exercise had improved to such a degree that the assigned work rate was now below the critical power;7 they were able to tolerate the work rate essentially indefinitely.

Peter Calverley’s laboratory investigated the combination of helium and oxygen breathing. In a crossover design, patients with COPD performed an endurance shuttle walk test while breathing air, 28% oxygen in nitrogen, 21% oxygen in helium, or 28% oxygen in helium.8 The latter mixture (high helium, high oxygen) yielded the highest shuttle walk distance. Whether 28% oxygen and 72% helium represents the optimal high oxygen/low density mixture for improving exercise tolerance remains to be determined.

A multicentre study showed that the benefits of a rehabilitative treadmill training programme were enhanced in a group of COPD patients receiving an effective long acting anticholinergic bronchodilator compared with a group receiving placebo.9 By the end of the training programme, the duration of a constant work rate treadmill task was increased by 79% in patients receiving bronchodilator treatment compared with those receiving placebo.

Finally, in this issue of Thorax, Peters et al report that 50% oxygen breathing acts synergistically with bronchodilator therapy (ipratropium bromide) to reduce hyperinflation and improve exercise tolerance in patients with COPD.10 In a crossover study in 16 patients, the mean tolerance of a constant work rate increased by 57% and 31% when inhaling oxygen or receiving bronchodilator, respectively. The combination of oxygen and ipratropium increased exercise tolerance by an average of 87% over the control condition, demonstrating an approximately additive response.

The mathematically inclined among us will note that only four of six possible permutations of these four interventions have so far been reported. The successful combinations of heliox with exercise training and of bronchodilators with heliox are waiting to be achieved. Further, can studies of the simultaneous application of three interventions be far behind? Four studies of this kind could be planned, the requirement being the necessity to prove the superiority of the exercise tolerance improvements in response to three interventions over that of three groups in which combinations of two of the three interventions are applied. Will we see the day when a study appears in which simultaneous application of all four of these physiological manoeuvres are combined to ameliorate exercise intolerance and are proved to be superior to three groups in which three of the four interventions are given? One can only dream.

New combined approaches to reduce dynamic hyperinflation improve exercise intolerance in patients with COPD


View Abstract


  • Funding: Dr Casaburi is the Grancell/Burns Chair in the Rehabilitative Sciences.

  • Competing interests: Dr Casaburi is a member of the speaker’s bureau and is a consultant to Boehringer-Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals and Pfizer Pharmaceuticals.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles

  • Airwaves
    Wisia Wedzicha