rss
Thorax 2000;55:722 doi:10.1136/thorax.55.8.722
  • Letters to the editor

“Opportunist” mycobacterial infections

  1. P D O DAVIES
  1. University Hospital
  2. Aintree
  3. Liverpool L9 7AL
  4. UK
  5. Imperial College School of Medicine
  6. London SW3 6LY
  7. UK
  1. Dr J M Grange email:sophia{at}hagia.freeserve.co.uk
  1. J M GRANGE
  1. University Hospital
  2. Aintree
  3. Liverpool L9 7AL
  4. UK
  5. Imperial College School of Medicine
  6. London SW3 6LY
  7. UK
  1. Dr J M Grange email:sophia{at}hagia.freeserve.co.uk

    We were greatly impressed by the Joint Tuberculosis Committee guidelines on the management of opportunist mycobacterial infections.1 We do, however, wonder why the word “opportunist” has been used to describe the mycobacteria, other than the M tuberculosis complex, that cause human disease. All mycobacteria causing disease, even theM tuberculosis complex, are opportunists. Thus, the latter are often spoken of as causing opportunist disease in HIV positive persons. Since the causative role of these other mycobacteria in human disease was established in the middle of the 20th century, a wide range of collective nouns has been applied to them—atypical, anonymous, MOTT (mycobacteria other than tuberculosis), non-tuberculous, and tuberculoid—as well as opportunist.

    The distinguishing feature of almost all mycobacteria other than members of the M tuberculosis complex is that they live freely in the environment. For this reason the expression “environmental mycobacteria” has been in widespread use in recent years. May we suggest that, for uniformity, this expression should be universally adopted.

    References

    1. I A CAMPBELL, Chairman of the Joint Tuberculosis Committee's
    1. Working Party on Opportunist Mycobacteria
      1. L P ORMEROD, Chairman of the Joint Tuberculosis Committee
      1. Working Party on Opportunist Mycobacteria

          authors' reply The term “opportunist mycobacteria” was suggested by Marks.1-1 He argued that M tuberculosis, M bovis, and M leprae were obligate pathogens which, if they did get into the environment, could not survive for any significant length of time. The other mycobacteria that cause disease in humans are, as Drs Davies and Grange say, free living environmental organisms and we are all continually exposed to them. However, comparatively few people become infected. Those who do usually have some pre-existing condition which predisposes them to infection—for example, chronic bronchitis and emphysema, bronchiectasis, previous tuberculosis, or some form of immunosuppression. The mycobacteria that are free living in the environment thus need an opportunity to cause disease—hence “opportunist mycobacteria”. It should also be pointed out that not all environmental bacteria cause disease. The nomenclature was discussed both by the Working Party and the full Joint Tuberculosis Committee; in both it was agreed by substantial majorities. This decision is also supported by the current and former directors of the Mycobacterium Reference Unit for England and Wales. We had hoped that the nomenclature argument about this group of mycobacteria could have been laid to rest once and for all after these decisions.

          References

          1. 1-1.

          This Article

          Services

          1. Request permissions

          Social bookmarking

          Register for free content


          Free sample
          This recent issue is free to all users to allow everyone the opportunity to see the full scope and typical content of Thorax.
          View free sample issue >>

          Free archive
          The full back archive is now available for Thorax. Institutional subscribers may access the entire archive as part of their subscription. Personal subscribers will also have access to all content when logged in. Non-subscribers who register have free access to all articles published before 2006, back to volume 1 issue 1.
          Register to access the free archive >>

          Don't forget to sign up for content alerts so you keep up to date with all the articles as they are published.