Article Text
Statistics from Altmetric.com
The importance of presenting absolute cell numbers when counting cells in biological samples is illustrated by the potentially misleading interpretation of data in the paper by Marco Confalonieri and colleagues.1 The authors concluded that, in addition to reduced sputum neutrophilia, the number of sputum macrophages increased significantly following treatment with inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate in patients with COPD. However, the observed increase in the proportion of sputum macrophages from 19.6% before treatment to 35.8% following treatment is entirely attributable to the reduced number of sputum neutrophils. From the data presented in the paper, the absolute numbers of different cells in the sputum can be calculated (table 1), revealing that the absolute sputum macrophage count was essentially unchanged following treatment. It is important that the absolute numbers of cells, and not simply their proportions, are presented when measuring differential cell counts in sputum or any other biological sample.
- In this window
- In a new window
References
- ↵
authors’ reply We would like to thank Dr Hart for his useful comment. We agree that it is important that the absolute numbers of cells are presented when measuring differential cell count in a biological sample. In fact, fig 1 of our paper illustrated the reduction of sputum neutrophils as absolute cell numbers. We thank Dr Hart for the table where the data have been presented as mean absolute cell counts, showing no difference in the absolute number of macrophages after treatment and confirming that the increase in the proportion of sputum macrophages following treatment is attributable …